Back
Professional indemnity insurance in Hong Kong today
By Glenn Haley and Geoffrey Shaw

Question:
I am a building maintenance engineer and would like to know more about professional negligence.
1. What is its definition?
2. What are the procedures if there is a case of professional negligence?
3. Is it a normal practice for construction professionals in Hong Kong; that is, architects, surveyors or engineers to obtain professional indemnity insurance (it is common in the UK)?

Answer:
Your question raises some issues that are of considerable practical importance to engineers in private practice (and also to those who engage the services of engineers).

What is "professional negligence"?
Negligence can be defined broadly as careless behaviour or omission that causes personal injury or property damage. In order for an injured party to succeed in a claim for negligence, the injured party must prove, on the balance of probabilities, the following:
1. that there is a duty of care owed to him by the allegedly guilty party, who for present purposes will be the engineer;
2. that the engineer has acted or spoken (or failed to act) in a way that breached that duty of care; and
3. that the injured party has suffered relevant damages as a consequence of the breach.

As regards (1) above, the existence or otherwise of a duty of care in negligence sometimes is difficult to establish. However, for present purposes we may assume that an engineer does owe a duty of care to his client (with such duty being a duty that exists concurrently with whatever duties or obligations are owed by the engineer to his client under their consultancy contract). It is a more difficult question whether the engineer also owes a duty of care towards persons who are not his client. In the construction industry, the current state of the law seems to be that, although the engineer does owe a duty of care to his client, he does not - under usual circumstances - owe a duty of care to the client's contractors and sub-contractors.

As regards (2) above, the normal standard of care in negligence cases is the standard of a "reasonable person". However, professional negligence tends to focus on a more rigorous standard of care, namely, the standard of a reasonable person in the same profession (possibly even the same discipline) as the engineer in question. This standard is established by reference to what is the generally accepted practice within the relevant branch or discipline of the profession. Therefore, an engineer is bound to exercise a degree of care, skill and knowledge which ordinarily is exercised by reasonably competent members of the profession, who have the same rank and profess the same specialisation as the engineer in question.

Unlike solicitors, engineers do not generally owe any "fiduciary" duties to their clients. Therefore, engineers only need to be concerned with the duties imposed on them under their contract and/or by the law of negligence. Fiduciary duties are separate and distinct from duties that are owed under contract and/or negligence. They are duties that the law places upon people who are trusted by others and by reason of their power and authority, they are in a position that allows them to abuse that trust and power for their own interests.

What is professional indemnity insurance?
A professional indemnity insurance policy is a contract between the insured engineer and the insurer (that is, insurance company) in which the insurer promises to indemnify the engineer against claims brought against him by third parties, normally his clients or other persons affected, arising from the activities of or services provided by the engineer. The type of risks and activities covered by the professional indemnity insurance depends, of course, upon the terms of each individual insurance policy. The extent of coverage is described in the insuring clause and is usually described in terms of the activities of the engineer, causes of action and remedies that an injured party might seek against the engineer.

However, most insurance contracts incorporate an upper limit on the amount of indemnity granted by the insurer for each claim or per policy year. In Hong Kong, the upper limit for professional indemnity insurance policies in the construction industry is often as low as HK$1 million. The extent of coverage for professional negligence under each policy therefore depends on the type of risks and activities covered as well as the upper limit of indemnity granted under the insurance policy. Through obtaining and maintaining appropriate professional indemnity insurance, engineers effectively can protect themselves against the risk of claims that arise from professional negligence.

It is common for professional indemnity insurance to be of a "claim made and notified" policy. This essentially means that the insurer will indemnify the engineer for any claim that is made against the engineer within the duration of the insurance policy, no matter when the defined event on which the claim is based occurred, provided that the engineer notifies the insurer within the time limit stipulated in the policy. It usually requires that the engineer to notify the insurer as soon as practicable upon the engineer's knowledge of the claim or potential claim.

What are the required procedures if there is a claim of professional negligence?
There is no set or single procedure to be followed. Each case and claim needs to be analysed individually.

In very broad terms, a claim of professional negligence often involves the following sequence of events:
* An act, advice or omission by the insured engineer.
* Someone suffers loss as a result of the act, advice or omission by the engineer.
* The injured party complains to the engineer, probably asking for compensation.
* The engineer notifies its insurer. (This is a crucial step. If the engineer wishes to preserve the protection of his insurance cover, he must notify the insurer promptly and strictly in accordance with the policy wording. Debating the matter with the complaining client, and/or delaying in making the notification, and/or "trying to sort the matter out" without involving the insurer, can lead to the insurer being able to refuse to cover the claim under the policy.)
* The insurer investigates the claim. The insurer usually reserves its position as to indemnity (liability and quantum of liability) pending completion of its investigation.
* The insurer either accepts or rejects the claim.
* The insurer accepts the claim and grants indemnity and defends the proceedings commenced by the injured party by instructing solicitors or settling the claim with the injured party; or
* The insurer rejects the claim and declines indemnity and the engineer has to handle the claim himself. The engineer may institute proceedings against the insurer to challenge the insurer's refusal. Even if the insurer accepts the claim, there may still be issues in relation to the monetary amount of indemnity granted by the insurer. If the engineer thinks the amount of indemnity should be higher, the engineer may institute proceedings against the insurer to challenge that.
* The court determines the extent of the engineer's liability (if any) to the claimant and the quantum of that liability, or alternatively the parties settle the claim and the insurer pays the injured party his entitlement up to the amount of the indemnity granted.


Notification of claim
It is very important for the engineer, upon receipt of the letter of complaint or claim or demand, to give prompt notice to his insurer about the claim or potential claim. Since it is common for professional indemnity insurance to be a "claim made and notified" policy, if the insurer is not notified within the time limit stipulated in the insurance policy, the insurer will decline indemnity and the engineer will be left to deal with the claim purely from his own resources. If, during the period of insurance, the engineer becomes aware of any fact or circumstances that may give rise to a claim, it is advisable for the engineer to notify his insurer immediately of such fact or circumstances. This is because any subsequent claim which arises from such fact or circumstances (and of which the insurer was notified during the period of insurance) is deemed to be a claim made during the period of insurance, irrespective of whether the claim is actually made during the period of insurance.

After the insurer is notified of the claim or potential claim, it will determine whether the claim is covered under the engineer's insurance policy. Once the insurer accepts the claim, the insurer may obtain legal advice on its indemnity liability as well as the engineer's liability in the claim and the quantum of those liabilities (if any). If proceedings already have been commenced against the engineer, the insurer will instruct solicitors to handle the proceedings and to act for both the insurer and the engineer. The insurer's solicitors therefore represent the engineer in the conduct of the proceedings. The engineer maintains an important role as a witness in the proceedings and his co-operation is required for the insurer's solicitors adequately to defend the claim.

In some cases, the insurer may reserve its right to decline indemnity until more information is revealed about the claim. Under such circumstances, the engineer probably would have to defend the claim and fund the proceedings personally, usually by instructing his own solicitors. The insurer is likely to wait until the issues on the extent and quantum of the engineer's liability have been determined by court before determining whether it is liable to grant indemnity. If the insurer determines that it is liable to grant indemnity and the quantum of that liability, it will reimburse the engineer for the amount paid under the claim up to the limit of the indemnity.

Is it common for construction professionals in Hong Kong to maintain professional indemnity insurance?

It is very common for construction professionals in the US, the UK and Australia to maintain professional indemnity insurance. In the past, it was less common for construction professionals in Hong Kong to obtain indemnity insurance. In recent years, it has become more common for construction professionals in Hong Kong to obtain indemnity insurance, both for the general coverage of a professional's practice and for work done under specific contracts. This change is probably due to the requirement in many building and construction contracts (usually in the special conditions) for the contractor or engineer to take out and maintain effective professional indemnity insurance during the contractual period.

About the authors: Glenn Haley and Geoffrey Shaw are partners with the Construction and Enginering Department of Deacons Hong Kong. If you have a legal question about engineering or construction law, please submit them to the editor.

Explore Hong Kong Engineer